follow us:

Latest News

Catching up with Koretzky
Michael Koretzky, Society of Professional Journalists region 3 director, had a busy summer. For months, he received abuse on both side of the #Gamergate argument when planning his event, Airplay, and to have the event end early due to a bomb threat. Michael also talks about ... [read more]
Get lucky in the wasteland with Fallout 4
The next episode of S.P.E.C.I.A.L. by Bethesda shows the power of Lady Luck. Being the seventh letter in the acronym, Luck plays a huge role in Fallout 4.... [read more]
Spartan Companies keeps Halo players in good company
Halo Spartan Companies allows for like-minded players to meet up on the battlefield in Halo 5: Guardians. ... [read more]

Latest Articles

Smite Preview: Hey look at me, I'm playing a MOBA on my console
There's no doubt that the top two MOBA games are DotA 2 and League of Legends, and with the control layout for those games, it's unlikely we'll see those games make the jump to the consoles. However, Smite, the third-person perspective MOBA game and arguably the third most p... [read more]
It doesn't matter how you get your Gjallarhorn
Destiny has seen its share of ups and downs. From the amazingly unbalanced Vex Mythoclast Fusion Rifle to its poor story, players have had plenty of reasons to trash the game. And now, the ultimate storm of garbage has landed. The Destiny community lost its mind when the Gja... [read more]
Gears of War: Ultimate Edition Beta shows that the series still has some fight
The Gears of War: Ultimate Edition beta has ended and it has been an experience. With only multiplayer available to play, I was in game after game of Team Deathmatch and King of the Hill. With a shiny new presentation and new features, is this attempt enough to re-ignite th... [read more]

Latest Reviews

Batman: Arkham Knight Review: A fitting end for the Dark Knight
Rocksteady Studios did the unthinkable in 2009 by making a game based on a comic an actual GOTY contender. The follow-up, Arkham City, continued the pattern of quality and faithfulness to the comic making for another great game. To finish off the series, Rocksteady is back w... [read more]
Heroes of the Storm Review: The WoW of MOBAs is here
MOBAs are becoming more and more common as the competitive arena of choice. League of Legends and DotA changed the face of eSports by putting the new genre in the spotlight. Blizzard has entered the fray with their answer in the form of Heroes of the Storm.... [read more]
Dying Light Review: What happens when you do Dead Island correctly
Zombie massacre simulator is the description that comes to mind when I think of Techland's Dying Light. With so many implements of undead doom at your disposal, you can easily lose yourself in trying every weapon and item you come across. The real question, though, is does t... [read more]

Latest Videos

8-Bit Eric Review: Yoshi's Woolly World
8-Bit Eric reviews the woolly adventure of Yoshi in Yoshi's Woolly World. ... [read more]
8-Bit Eric Review: Citizens of Earth Review (Wii U)
Remember Earthbound? Well, Citizens of Earth is like Earthbound, but not really. 8-Bit Eric explains why. ... [read more]
Let's Play - Her Story Pt. 1-3
Her Story is a different take on the adventure genre formula. There's a mystery to be solved, but instead of solving puzzles or talking to people, all you have to do is search for the right video. ... [read more]
Ar tonelico Qoga Knell of Ar Ciel Review
Posted on June 28, 2011 by

When you hear the words "music rpg," what comes to mind? To me I thought it would be one part Guitar Hero and one part Football Manager, almost like the type of game you would find on Facebook. What I didn’t expect were cutesy anime girls, their songs making my party stronger and them stripping their clothes in the middle of battle to gain stronger magic.

Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel is the third entry of the series and the first one on the PS3 from Gust and brought to the US by NIS America. Now, I’m new to the series so I’m jumping into this game blind. But it has cute anime girls letting me dive into them so they can get stronger magic. That’s a plus right?


R.A.H. - R.A.H. or Realtime Active Hymnetics is the battle system used, and is one of the more interesting systems that I have seen in a JRPG. What it is that the Reyateil (the game’s mages) use song magic to make their Vanguards stronger, buff their defenses or give themselves more powerful magic. In other words, as they sing the party gets stronger. As for the Vanguards if they time their attacks to the song they can help increase the Reyateil’s power. A "harmogrpah" helps players with their timing. By doing this will have the girls purge their clothes off. The stronger the magic, the more clothes come off.

Diving - In order to gain strong song magic, you will have to dive into the character's Cosmosphere (inner conscience) to unlock their inner powers. There are shops scattered that allow you to go in and try to draw out that magic. The deeper you go in them, the stronger magic you can unlock and even release multiple personas for each character.

Visual Novel Elements - Now these girls are not going to just let you dive into them or strip in the middle of a battle just like that. It takes a bit of smooth talking and some carefully picked choices to do that. Visual novel elements are no strangers to JRPGs, but they are heavily present in this game and it is a nice addition.

Multiple Endings - In keeping with the visual novel formula, the two main Reyateil, Saki and Finnel, each have two endings; good and normal. This totals up to four altogether and so the game will require a couple of playthroughs to see all the endings.


Battle system - While the R.A.H system is unique, it has some heavy flaws. One of them is having to time your attacks with the music. Sounds easy, right, just feel a rhythm to the battle music and then time the attacks to it. Well, not exactly, players will have to keep an eye on the harmograph rather than listing to the music. This really overcomplicates things. In most cases (or at least in my case) it was filled with low peaks and a few high ones. This is due to the mood of the Reyateil at the time of battle and what accessories she has on. This kind of makes it hard to fight since there is a lot going on during the battle; multiple enemies outnumbering you, party AI dying, and to top it off, the Reyateil are defenseless and need the Vanguards to protect them. Now I understand the importance of defending a mage, but don’t all mages have some sort of defense spell they could cast? Or, oh I don’t know, maybe move out of the way when an enemy gets too close.

Often Useless Party AI - Speaking of the party AI, it is often useless and more than once I had to take control of them. Sure, there’s a setting in the battle menu to have them go on offense or defense, but it doesn’t help much. And speaking of useless, let me bring up the Reyateil again. I get it that she’s a mage and that the party needs to protect her, but come on. Don’t just stand there when an enemy is charging at you. Run, cast a protect spell or a defensive spell. Just do something other than just stand there.



Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel is one of those games that you have to play in order to understand. Explaining it will only just get you lost and confused, just ask any fans of JRPGs when they try to explain a game to the average gamer. While it is not totally a bad game, Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel just wasn't my cup of tea. No amount of fan service can distract me from its useless party AI and overcomplicated battle system. Fans of the series will want to pick it up even if it’s just for the art book and music CD.

What's your most anticipated game for November?

Call of Duty: Black Ops III
Starcraft II: Legacy of the Void
Fallout 4
Star Wars Battlefront
The Crew: Wild Run
Animal Crossing: amiibo Festival
Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash
Need for Speed
Rise of the Tomb Raider
View Results - View Comments


Catching up with Koretzky

Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning Review

Rise of the Argonauts Review

Rise of the Argonauts Review

Other Gaming News From The Web