follow us:

Latest News

Watch the PlayStation E3 2015 conference live at movie theaters
Go big or go home as Sony is once again bringing the PlayStation E3 2015 presser to movie theaters in North America. ... [read more]
Guitar Hero turns up the volume with heavy tracks
The Guitar Hero Facebook page revealed new metal and alternative tracks for the upcoming Guitar Hero Live on #TracklistTuesday. ... [read more]
The Evil Within’s final DLC introduces a new evil perspective
The Evil Within’s last DLC allows you to play as the Keeper in a brand new first-person camera mode. ... [read more]

Latest Articles

Evolve, day 1 DLC, and the entitlement of gamers
Evolve hasn’t been out for 72 hours yet and gamers have already decided to make it public enemy number 1. This is thanks to the umbrella claim of “2K charging full price for an incomplete game, as well as for DLC that should have been included with the original purchase.... [read more]
PAX South Tour Guide Pt. 3 - Quick Tips
So far we’ve told you what to do in San Antonio as well as where to eat and drink while at PAX South. Now we have a few quick tips for those traveling to our great city. ... [read more]
The OG Replay for Jan. 19
We're less than a week from PAX South and everyone here is excited. Not only is one of the biggest gaming events coming to our home city of San Antonio, but we're going to have our own panel. ... [read more]

Latest Reviews

Dying Light Review: What happens when you do Dead Island correctly
Zombie massacre simulator is the description that comes to mind when I think of Techland's Dying Light. With so many implements of undead doom at your disposal, you can easily lose yourself in trying every weapon and item you come across. The real question, though, is does t... [read more]
Tales From the Borderlands Ep. 1 Review: This time Telltale won't make you cry...that much
There are plenty of things to kill you on the planet of Pandora: the wildlife, bandits, and even $10,000,000. Or at least, that is if you are Rhys and Vaughn from Hyperion. The two of them are just a part of the cast in the first episode of Telltale’s Tales from the Borde... [read more]
The Order 1886 Review: A solid start to a possible big franchise
There are things that The Order gets it right, but has left plenty of room for improvement, which hopefully gets addressed in a sequel. ... [read more]

Latest Videos

8-Bit Eric Review: Guacamelee Super Turbo Championship Edition
8-Bit Eric knows a bit about wrestling. That's why he's the perfect reviewer for Guacamelee Super Turbo Championship Edition for the Wii U. ... [read more]
PAX South 2015: 8-Bit Eric does a Starr Mazer interview...kind of
On display at PAX South was a game called Starr Mazer, which mashes shmup gameplay with point-and-click adventure gameplay. 8-Bit Eric tried to do an interview with the developer, and well, you'll have to see what happens. ... [read more]
8-Bit Eric: Shiny the Firefly Review
8-Bit Eric takes a look at Shiny the Firefly on the Wii U. An indie game developed by Padaone games where you control a firefly on a rescue mission to protect its babies.... [read more]
Ar tonelico Qoga Knell of Ar Ciel Review
Posted on June 28, 2011 by

When you hear the words "music rpg," what comes to mind? To me I thought it would be one part Guitar Hero and one part Football Manager, almost like the type of game you would find on Facebook. What I didn’t expect were cutesy anime girls, their songs making my party stronger and them stripping their clothes in the middle of battle to gain stronger magic.

Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel is the third entry of the series and the first one on the PS3 from Gust and brought to the US by NIS America. Now, I’m new to the series so I’m jumping into this game blind. But it has cute anime girls letting me dive into them so they can get stronger magic. That’s a plus right?

ON THE BEAT

R.A.H. - R.A.H. or Realtime Active Hymnetics is the battle system used, and is one of the more interesting systems that I have seen in a JRPG. What it is that the Reyateil (the game’s mages) use song magic to make their Vanguards stronger, buff their defenses or give themselves more powerful magic. In other words, as they sing the party gets stronger. As for the Vanguards if they time their attacks to the song they can help increase the Reyateil’s power. A "harmogrpah" helps players with their timing. By doing this will have the girls purge their clothes off. The stronger the magic, the more clothes come off.

Diving - In order to gain strong song magic, you will have to dive into the character's Cosmosphere (inner conscience) to unlock their inner powers. There are shops scattered that allow you to go in and try to draw out that magic. The deeper you go in them, the stronger magic you can unlock and even release multiple personas for each character.

Visual Novel Elements - Now these girls are not going to just let you dive into them or strip in the middle of a battle just like that. It takes a bit of smooth talking and some carefully picked choices to do that. Visual novel elements are no strangers to JRPGs, but they are heavily present in this game and it is a nice addition.

Multiple Endings - In keeping with the visual novel formula, the two main Reyateil, Saki and Finnel, each have two endings; good and normal. This totals up to four altogether and so the game will require a couple of playthroughs to see all the endings.


OUT OF TUNE

Battle system - While the R.A.H system is unique, it has some heavy flaws. One of them is having to time your attacks with the music. Sounds easy, right, just feel a rhythm to the battle music and then time the attacks to it. Well, not exactly, players will have to keep an eye on the harmograph rather than listing to the music. This really overcomplicates things. In most cases (or at least in my case) it was filled with low peaks and a few high ones. This is due to the mood of the Reyateil at the time of battle and what accessories she has on. This kind of makes it hard to fight since there is a lot going on during the battle; multiple enemies outnumbering you, party AI dying, and to top it off, the Reyateil are defenseless and need the Vanguards to protect them. Now I understand the importance of defending a mage, but don’t all mages have some sort of defense spell they could cast? Or, oh I don’t know, maybe move out of the way when an enemy gets too close.

Often Useless Party AI - Speaking of the party AI, it is often useless and more than once I had to take control of them. Sure, there’s a setting in the battle menu to have them go on offense or defense, but it doesn’t help much. And speaking of useless, let me bring up the Reyateil again. I get it that she’s a mage and that the party needs to protect her, but come on. Don’t just stand there when an enemy is charging at you. Run, cast a protect spell or a defensive spell. Just do something other than just stand there.
 


 

 

Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel is one of those games that you have to play in order to understand. Explaining it will only just get you lost and confused, just ask any fans of JRPGs when they try to explain a game to the average gamer. While it is not totally a bad game, Ar toneclico Qoga: Knell of Ar Ciel just wasn't my cup of tea. No amount of fan service can distract me from its useless party AI and overcomplicated battle system. Fans of the series will want to pick it up even if it’s just for the art book and music CD.
 

What's your most anticipated game for June?

Batman: Arkham Knight
BlazBlue: Chrono Phantasma Extend
The Elder Scrolls Online: Tamriel Unlimited
J-Stars Victory Vs+
View Results - View Comments

Podcast


#Gamergate debate talk with SPJ's Michael Koretzky


Warhammer Online: Age of Reckoning Review

Rise of the Argonauts Review

Rise of the Argonauts Review

Other Gaming News From The Web